Need a little help...

I want to try (try being the operative word) to make my Mom a Christmas gift. I am thinking a sleeve or bag for her Ipad which she is currently obsessed with!!

Here is the one I am thinking of doing!! 

What I need help with, is picking a fabric! So opinions please...

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

 I tried to pick ones I think would suit my Mom. Any opinions are welcome!! SO please chime in!! THANKS!